Friday at 20:183 days comment_56291 Hi,I’m a surveyor by background, and a qualified fire door inspector, and I also install fire doors through my own business. I know my way around fire doors, but I’ve hit some situations on a job where the right call isn’t obvious and I’d value experienced opinions. Photos are attached.Setting: A facility for retired people, where some residents are non-ambulant and use wheelchairs. Please look at the floor finishes in the photo, as I think they’re relevant. The doors appear to be notional (no third-party certification or labels). 1. Frame damage The frame is distorted at low level from repeated wheelchair strikes.I was planning to fill minor damage with a good-quality epoxy filler, but where does “minor” end and “replace the frame” begin? Is there a recognised limit on depth, width or extent?I know epoxy shouldn’t be used on edges. Would it be acceptable to chisel out the damaged section (say 10mm deep and 350 to 400 mm high), glue in a hardwood lip, then fill, sand and paint? Would that still count as a like-for-like repair under the BM TRADA Fire Door Maintenance Scheme or similar guidance?2. Door leaf damageThe leaves have the same wheelchair damage at low level.The hinges are painted over and very old. Trying to unscrew them risks snapping the screws, so I’d like to avoid removing the doors if I can. What’s the best approach for repairing the leaves in situ, and when would you say it’s time to replace the leaf rather than repair it? Can i cut a section of 350 to 400mm x 10mm deep and install a hardwood strip, glue it, fill tiny gaps with epoxy, sand and paint.Does anyone know any specific tools i can use to take off these screws without snapping them please.3. Sash lock plate removal and fixA number of doors have redundant strike plates (or sash lock plates) installed in the frame. I need to take them out to seal the smoke passage and i was planning to fill this gap with a good quality epoxy resin, sand it and then paint. Is this acceptable due to its depth? I can apply epoxy in 2 sessions to ensure epoxy sets hard. Can you advice on an other methods please. If I cut the whole section out and install hardwood strip that will be a lot of work because every door to the bedroom has the same problem and since it sits in the middle of the frame I thought epoxy will be safe to use.4. Excessive gaps at the head and bottomThe head gap is excessive and the bottom gap is about 20mm so a lot worse. Photo of head gap attached but the head gap is excessive in one corner only. It seems like someone shaved it in the corner. I am not sure how you fix this. Any good advice will be most appreciated. I can take it off and trim it so i can level it and then install it 2 to 3 mm higher but the hinges are 40 years old and painted and the screws might snap. For the 20mm bottom gap, the floor finish may be the cause. Can this be fixed without a raised threshold, given the residents’ wheelchair use? What type of drop seal is the best option here please.General question: Where do you personally draw the line between a justified repair and replacement, especially for notional doors with no certification to fall back on? Any advice or experience with similar care-sector settings would be hugely appreciated.Thanks in advance,HamidPS - I hope i have not repeated this. If I have I am sorry. Report
13 hours ago13 hr comment_56293 Looking at the images and reading your text, personally I would say that the doors and frames are at the end of life, even if it wasn’t in a care home, Triggers broom comes to mind. If they insist on repairs I would walk away and report it to the local fire authority. Report
3 hours ago3 hr comment_56298 What does the FRA say is the minimum acceptable standard?Are these even fire doors to the old standards or just doors someone has stuck seals and brushes into the frame?These look beyond reasonable repair, they have clearly never really been looked after and so have accumulated extensive defects - due to the risk profile of the occupants & likely evacuation strategy a higher standard would be usually expected. Report
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.